Dear Friends,
Have you heard about the movie “The Golden Compass?” Are you concerned that it is anti-catholic or even anti-Christian? Are you wondering if you, your children or your grandchildren should see it?
Here is why in my opinion the criticism is both right and wrong:
1) Philip Pullman, who wrote the books, is an avowed atheist. He has made no bones about his belief that religion is a negative force in society and that we as human beings have outgrown our need for superstitions like God. This message does find its way into the trilogy of books of which the Golden Compass is the first.
2) However, neither the Golden Compass movie nor the book really gets into this message—it’s not really clear until the second and third books. And the movie as I understand it has been extra careful to steer away from that message as well.
3) I have read all three books and enjoyed them immensely. Yes, I disagree with Pullman’s theology. But I love fantasy books and these are excellent fantasy books on their own merits. I do not agree with Pullman’s (anti-)religious views, but he has created a really impressive world with really impressive characters, both heroes and villains. Ostensibly children’s books, these stand up very well as adult fiction.
4) And, in fact, I welcome the fact that he has chosen to deal in his books with religious and moral issues. No less a person than the Archbishop of Canterbury has championed the books for this reason. You can read a fascinating interview between Pullman, the author, and Archbishop Rowan Williams at the website of the English newspaper, the Guardian. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/arts/main.jhtml?xml=/arts/2004/03/17/bodark17.xml&page=3
5) There is also an excellent review of the movie from a Christian perspective on the website of Christianity Today. It includes a very interesting comparison between this series and C.S. Lewis’ Chronicles of Narnia.http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2007/december/12.36.html?gclid=COvchJvOoZACFRpdagodgFyl8g
6) Finally, I urge you to make up your own mind. Watch the movie, read the books, and decide for yourself what you think. Don’t be afraid of different ideas. The truth of God has survived much worse foes than this.
7) Questions? Concerns? Drop me a line. If folks are interested, I would be happy to organize a movie discussion session after Christmas.
Sincerely,
Fr. Eric
No comments:
Post a Comment